Bayesian Workflow [book reviews]

I thought I had posted a full-length review of the Bayesian Workflow, but the fact is I haven’t! Here is the blurb I wrote (upon request) for Chapman & Hall (and reproduced on Andrew’s blog):

“This original, thought-provoking, and transformative book is much much more than an implementation manual for Bayesian Data Analysis, even though it shares almost the same perspective. (The first sentence of the book states that the authors’ “conceptions of statistical practice, and of Bayesian statistics, have changed over the years”.) By providing a modus vivendi for undertaking Bayesian modelling from scratch in realistic settings where models are not magicked out of the blue, the authors explicit and rationalise the many steps required by such a bottom-up modelling protocol (“not a checklist, not a cookbook”, and not a flowchart!) in real situations. The contents read very well and very smoothly, with a seamless conjunction of intuition, modelling advices, computational details, and comparison tools. While unsurprisingly Bayesian, the perspective adopted therein remains both open and inclusive, with a welcome humility about the limitations and challenges of Bayesian workflows. This book should thus appeal to and profit a wide variety of readers, as providing guidance through an extensive collection of highly detailed examples, with shared code and exercises.”

One Response to “Bayesian Workflow [book reviews]”

  1. Andrew Gelman's avatar
    Andrew Gelman Says:

    Hi, Christian. Thanks for the review. By the way, you can (indirectly) thank Bob Carpenter for the “not a checklist, not a cookbook” line in our book. I don’t remember the details, but at some point a few months ago I showed a near-complete version of the book and he said we should be more clear on what we mean by “workflow.” Is it a checklist? A cookbook? Or something different. I responded that, no, it’s not a checklist or a cookbook–and then I realized it would be a good idea to say this in the book!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Xi'an's Og

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading