Archive for Fields medal

Nature tidbits [10 Sept 2026]

Posted in Books, pictures, Travel, University life with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , on October 21, 2026 by xi'an

Having left my copy of the 10 September issue of Nature on a suburban train this afternoon (hopefully to the benefit of a fellow passenger!), I had to fall back on the online version. The cover story, Taming turbulence, is about HydroGym, a reinforcement-learning platform where AI agents learn to control turbulent flows. While this has practical consequences, it is also the harbinger of the resolution (?) of the Navier-Stoke Millennium Problem by OpenAI. Covered in the following issue.

Flotsam of interest for me:

  • reporting on a single data point exciting cosmologists (and beyond!), namely one unusual flash recorded in 2023 or 2024 by the LZ detector thru its 10 tonnes liquid xenon basin, which looks like what a weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP!) would produce. This would be a fist in experimentally supporting the dark matter theory. But without reproducibility, ’tis hard to jump to a conclusion. In correlation, a news article on the launch of the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope, with two World Views, one on Roman herself as “mother of Hubble”. Promising advances on far, far away celestial bodies thanks to the infrared abilities of said telescope. And again to cosmology.
  • a news feature on “the Einstein test”, checking whether language models trained only on pre-1905 data could rediscover relativity. This is a clever way to separate creativity from regurgitation, if the historical training corpus can indeed be kept clean. And faster than training monkeys to type…
  • an article combining climate and econometric modelling to assess how human-induced climate change has shifted, and will shift, the burden of childhood malaria in Africa. The attribution relies on counterfactual climate simulations, which makes me wonder about the propagation of uncertainty.
  • an article linking US mortgage records from around the Second World War to race and immigration status. It shows that New Deal programmes disproportionately excluded Black borrowers, a nice (if sad) record-linkage exercise.
  • a privacy feature on how UK Biobank was shut down after a data leak and is now imposing new safety measures. It raises the recurrent tension between protecting participants’ privacy and keeping data open to researchers, which connects once more with the membership-inference paper I discussed earlier.
  • an editorial praising the World Bank for publishing and verifying the raw data and code behind its reports. Other agencies should indeed follow suit!
  • a news item on the massive experience of mutating every DNA letter in a viral genome, whose effects the top AI models failed to predict (fail or pass the survival test!). A welcome reality check on AI in biology.

  • two militant comments on the economy, one by Joseph Stiglitz et al. calling for an IPCC-like International Panel on Inequality, and one on a call for measuring growth through all forms of capital, rather than GDP alone. And a great poster (reminding me of Indian movie posters) on the side!
  • an editorial on the comforting aspect of the Ig Nobel prizes, no matter how silly they sound.
  • a book review of The Winding Trail &tc. on the Principia Mathematica and Newton’s disdain for hypotheses (with his famous “hypotheses non fingo” that clashes with the modern scientific approach!), along with his habit of feuding over priority. What is amazing with Newton’s meteor trajectory is he only seriously engage into mathematics during his final undergraduate term at Cambridge, one year before the Great Plague and his revolutionary breakthroughs!

a severe misalignment of AI in Mathematics [reposted]

Posted in Kids, Statistics, University life with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , on October 14, 2026 by xi'an

[A Fields Medallists declaration that also appeared in Le Monde last weekend, about the chAInsaw massacre that LLMs solving open math problems and conjectures represents.]

Over the last few months, the mathematical capabilities of LLMs have improved dramatically, to the point that they can solve major outstanding problems in many fields of mathematics. However, the push by AI companies to solve mathematical problems as a benchmark is detrimental to the science of mathematics, and to the mathematical community. The goals of the AI companies and the goals of the mathematical community are severely misaligned. We see these as part of broader alignment issues impacting other scientific and creative professions, as well as the whole of society.

Research mathematics deals with understanding basic structures of shapes, numbers, and natural phenomena. Over the course of generations, it has built a large corpus of sophisticated ideas, methods, abstractions, and other tools to comprehend the mathematical landscape. In turn, modern technologies and sciences are based on mathematical tools.

Famous problems have often served as landmarks and lighthouses against which one can measure an improved understanding of this landscape. Solving one of these problems has been a certain sign of new insights and interesting methods, which would then be studied by a community of mathematicians, through a long and arduous process of talks, discussions, simplifications. At the end of this process, one will ideally find a textbook presentation of the results suitable for any graduate or even undergraduate student to study. Some of the mathematical ideas pursue their journey even further to become, decades or centuries after, tools that are understood and used by the whole population.

The mathematical community functions, in many ways, as a miniature version of humanity. It consists of individuals using a wide variety of different approaches, joined by core values. The most precious resources of our profession are students and ideas, and these we nurture with great care. We feel responsible to let them grow to their full potential, until they can live a life of their own in the mathematical world. For students we often suggest problems with the core intention of developing skills making them well-positioned for advances in research and elsewhere. Our ideas we disseminate in talks, private discussions and careful writeups, connecting them to the previous ideas of others. These processes invariably take time and are based on human interaction.

In recent months, the success of AI in solving major mathematical problems has made headlines even outside mathematical circles. But solving problems is only a tool and proxy for achieving the primary goal of conceptual understanding and insight. Forgetting this in the world of AI may turn the tool against the primary goal. Indeed, the mass production at faster and faster pace of “true/false” statements could destroy fertile ground instead of breathing life into new ideas.

Often these solutions are announced in a rush, leaving no time for a proper writeup, the isolation of new methods and ideas, and citing relevant previous work of others. As in all creative professions, this raises severe attribution and plagiarism questions. Moreover, without the willing mathematicians who must take care of their development and integration into the mathematical canon, AI-conceived ideas would never become fully alive and the crucial human transmission chain between mathematicians would be lost.

We are witnessing a general threat to intellectual work, with misalignment between the outcome of the use of AI and its initial purpose. In many fields and activities, years of training have traditionally served not only to produce a final answer or product, but also to develop understanding and the ability to formulate new questions and ideas. However, building on a vast body of previous human work, AI systems are becoming increasingly capable of producing the results of such work directly, and these goals cease to align. The issues the mathematical community faces now are similar to issues that other scientific and creative professions are facing, and indicate issues that all of humanity might face: how to make sure that, as AI changes the way work is done, we do not lose sight of what that work was meant to achieve in the first place.

AI offers the potential of enhancing and accelerating genuine mathematical study and understanding. Mathematics as a profession will need to adapt to these changes in several ways. However, whether these changes ultimately benefit the field or have a destructive effect will in large part be determined by the decisions of the humans in control of this new technology.

These issues must be addressed urgently, in the mathematical community, by the companies developing these technologies and, more broadly, by a society that will confront similar problems in many other forms of intellectual work.

  • Artur Avila (Fields Medal 2014)
  • Manjul Bhargava (Fields Medal 2014)
  • Caucher Birkar (Fields Medal 2018)
  • Pierre Deligne (Fields Medal 1978)
  • Yu Deng (Fields Medal 2026)
  • Simon Donaldson (Fields Medal 1986)
  • Vladimir Drinfeld (Fields Medal 1990)
  • Hugo Duminil-Copin (Fields Medal 2022)
  • Alessio Figalli (Fields Medal 2018)
  • Martin Hairer (Fields Medal 2014)
  • June Huh (Fields Medal 2022)
  • Maxim Kontsevich (Fields Medal 1998)
  • Elon Lindenstrauss (Fields Medal 2010)
  • Pierre-Louis Lions (Fields Medal 1994)
  • James Maynard (Fields Medal 2022)
  • Curtis McMullen (Fields Medal 1998)
  • Shigefumi Mori (Fields Medal 1990)
  • David Mumford (Fields Medal 1974)
  • Ngô Bảo Châu (Fields Medal 2010)
  • Andrei Okounkov (Fields Medal 2006)
  • Peter Scholze (Fields Medal 2018)
  • Stanislav Smirnov (Fields Medal 2010)
  • Terence Tao (Fields Medal 2006)
  • Maryna Viazovska (Fields Medal 2022)
  • Cédric Villani (Fields Medal 2010)
  • Wendelin Werner (Fields Medal 2006)
  • Efim Zelmanov (Fields Medal 1994)

Nature tidbits [6 Aug 2026]

Posted in Books, pictures, University life with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , on October 7, 2026 by xi'an

The 6 August issue of Nature arrived after my return from Japan, but it took me a while to catch up, the more because its cover story, Bloom service, about fertilising the oceans with iron as a carbon sink did not appeal much to the geoengineering sceptic in me. Nice pun though. Flotsam of interest for me:

  • an article on GPT-4 (and open-weight models) predicting the outcomes of 70 preregistered US survey experiments, 469 effects and 119,330 participants in total. The predicted treatment effects are highly correlated with the observed ones, about as well as pooled human forecasters do, including studies published after the training cutoff. But the predicted effect sizes are systematically too large, which is not a minor detail for a field still recovering from its replication crisis! Plus a survey of 460 social scientists about using LLMs for pilot testing, and a web app to “forecast” your own experiment’s effect before running it. (I wonder what a prior elicited this way would look like.)
  • a paper on membership inference attacks on medical AI models, showing that patients who differ from the majority are the easiest to identify as part of the training data, which I already discussed here. This fits the long-known issue with differential privacy and outliers.
  • a story on the four 2026 Fields Medals, announced at the ICM in Philadelphia, in fields far, far away:
    • Yu Deng (Chicago), for his work on PDEs, including a rigorous derivation of the Boltzmann equation from hard-sphere dynamics (with Zaher Hani and Xiao Ma), wave kinetic equations, and probabilistic approaches to nonlinear Schrödinger equations.
    • John Pardon (Stony Brook), for symplectic topology and enumerative geometry. He started as an undergraduate by answering a question of Gromov on knot distortion.
    • Jacob Tsimerman (Toronto), for extending techniques within arithmetic and complex algebraic geometry and solving conjectures in this field.
    • Hong Wang (NYU and IHES in Bures-sur-Yvette, almost a colleague!), for Fourier restriction, progress on Falconer’s conjecture and, with Joshua Zahl, the resolution of the Kakeya conjecture in three dimensions.
  • a feature on the scientific papers most cited in patents.
  • a news item on a Science paper by Blasi, Hamilton, Gray and Bowern, estimating that humanity may have spoken tens of thousands of languages between 3,000 and 1,000 years ago. The paper suggests a shift away from nomadic life triggered this diversity before it collapsed. I wonder at how deep the statistical linguistics inferring this rich past from the surviving sample goes. In a sense, the finding is not that surprising, given how isolated small prehistoric communities were, and how quickly a language drifts apart without contact. (I would also like to check how much the estimate depends on the assumed birth-and-death rates of languages, since the lost ones leave no trace to calibrate against…)
  • an editorial on the White House’s “new golden age for science” plan. It argues that such a golden age needs open borders and funding for the social sciences, public health and the humanities, not only AI and engineering. Alas, the now usual Trump.2.0 fare, with an AI funding roll-out in the news pages.
  • an emergency call by WHO director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus on why the WHO has never been more needed, and news that the first volunteer received an Ebola vaccine three months into the current outbreak.
  • a forecast that the coming El Niño should be the largest (by a mind-blowing margin) on record, pushing 2027 temperatures to new highs. And already having severe impact on tropical weather.
  • a scary comment on the risks of nuclear-powered merchant ships, in the very issue dated on the anniversary of Hiroshima…

AIs rushing to the proofs

Posted in Books, Kids, University life with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , , , on June 23, 2026 by xi'an

A “Feature” article in Nature (21 May 2026) and a long article in the New York Time (June 8, 2026) are both covering the sudden intrusion of AIs in proving or disproving mathematical conjectures… Genuine, hard, conjectures likes Erdös problems. Specialised AIs like Alethia, Math Inc., AlphaProof are hacking at existing open problems and a benchmark collection of problems whose solutions are not available (yet) called First Proof has been recently gathered, solved by OpenAI,  and is soon to be extended. In an earlier interview with Nature (27 April 2026), Terry Tao acknowledges the tectonic shift represented by this intrusion and how a mathematician’s skill need evolve. (This is also the starting point of the NYT story. ) A side issue of this is that reviewing the proofs thus produced by an AI may prove inhumane if it reaches hundreds of pages, which also relates to the un-academic (?) tendency of AIs companies to over-blow the results produced by their machines. For the times they are a-Changin…

The Guardian on [and on and on] Grothendieck

Posted in Books, Kids, Mountains, University life with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , , on September 11, 2024 by xi'an

A very looong piece in The Guardian of 31 August relates the life and achievements of Grothendieck in a highly romanticized way, hinting at hidden secrets contained in the tens of thousands of pages he wrote during his 26 years of retirement in Lasserre, Pyrénées… (Even when acknowledging that Grothendieck’s life and personality are providing enough fodder for a whole series of novels!)

“Grothendieck’s genius defied his attempts at erasing his own renown. He lurks in the background of one of Cormac McCarthy’s final novels, Stella Maris, as an éminence grise who leads on its psychically disturbed mathematician protagonist.”

With very little about maths, apart the mumbo-jumbo usually associated with non-specialists trying to convey the unique ability of a researcher with images and allegories aplenty! The only factual information is that Huawei sees worth in Grothendieck’s concept of topos (within his general theory of categories) toward future AIs and that they hired French 2002 Fields medalist Laurent Lafforgue to explore this subject (besides not mentioning Huawei creating an algebraic geometry chair at the IHÉS, the very place Grothendieck resigned from due to IHÉS receiving military funds).

“Applied to AI, toposes could allow computers to move beyond the data associated with, say, an apple; the geometric coordinates of how it appears in images, for example, or tagging metadata. Then AI could begin to identify objects more like we do – through a deeper “semantic” understanding of what an apple is. But practical application to create the next generation of “thinking” AI is, according to Lafforgue, some way off.”

The author of the Guardian piece, Phil Hoad, is also very reserved about the ultimate purpose of Huawei in funding this research (and the new Centre Lagrange in the centre of Paris), for its obscure links with the Chinese Government and the Chinese military, a concern also expressed by some French mathematicians who signed a tribune in 2021 calling for a boycott of the Centre… But leaving open the door open on whether or not the unexplored thousands of pages blackened by Grothendieck could contain mathematical gems, rather than esoteric ramblings aggravated by his complete shunning of society. Which sounds quite unlikely.